The Listeners by Maggie Stiefvater

For the bookstore’s upcoming literary fiction book club meeting, we chose The Listeners by Maggie Stiefvater, historical fiction from an author more famous for her YA fantasy novels. It takes place at a fictional luxury hotel in West Virginia in the 1940s, which was used to house Axis diplomats in the US while the government negotiated for a swap for American diplomats in Germany and Japan. The staff of the hotel, known for their impeccable service and devotion to their guests, found themselves in the position of serving the enemy, with no end in sight. This is a great premise for a book, but sadly The Listeners didn’t work for me. I wanted a deeper treatment of the way the Americans and the diplomats interacted, given their ideological and moral conflict – instead, their conversations barely scratched the surface. The writing was full of telling vs. showing, along with a lot of repetition, reflecting the author’s fundamental underestimating the reader’s ability to appreciate the story. At the same time, a confusing magical realism subplot was distracting and unnecessary. Overall, this could have been something much more complex and memorable, but insteadI found myself very eager to be finished. (I am not looking forward to moderating this discussion!)